In this series, I will be exploring one of our key research areas for this project—the sensory experience of pilgrimage. This first post will delve into one of the methodological approaches we have used for this investigation, how it relates to the broader archaeological field and how this manifests in practice as we investigate the experience of pilgrimage.

Understanding the Phenomenological Approach
Those who have been following our project for a while will have seen the term ‘phenomenological’ used in some of our blogs and posts—this is a key part of our methodological approach as we investigate the experience of pilgrimage by walking the routes we are researching. While phenomenological approaches may be well-known to archaeologists, what this means in both theory and practice can be less familiar for others.
Phenomenology began with roots in philosophy, and at its core emphasises human perspective, how a person experiences the world, and the fundamental entanglement between people and the world around us.[1] Phenomenology within a landscape archaeology context therefore considers the human experience of spaces, monuments and landscapes as essential to our understanding of it, and how this engagement could reciprocally affect both people and place. Crucially, it frames the body as well as the mind as a means by which we experience the world through our perspective and senses, dependent on where we are placed within it—to really understand a space, we have to be in it.[2]
Phenomenological archaeology saw its peak in the mid-to-late 1990s, and its efficacy as a standalone archaeological method in its own right has been debated.[3] Despite this, its legacy has fed into archaeological practice since and continues to inform some of the ways we approach understanding cultural landscapes.[4] To develop a richer understanding of archaeological sites, we can consider how a landscape was experienced by people of the past—how did sound travel around a site, and how might this affect where people spent their time? What could people see from different viewpoints in a settlement, and how did this affect their understanding of the world around them? To achieve this, researchers may place themselves within a site itself to better understand how it was perceived and experienced.

Pilgrimage and Perception
While for our project we do not suggest that we can entirely replicate or understand the experience of people of the past through this method, we can use field techniques inspired by previous work in phenomenological archaeology to supplement our research. This can provide a richer contextual understanding or present new avenues of investigation through our own experience.[5] For our project, this has meant walking along the routes that formed the pilgrimages we are researching. This research strand compares two pilgrimage routes—one in the UK between Norwich and Little Walsingham, and one in Japan known as the Ise Honkaido (伊勢本街道) that links Hase Temple (長谷寺) in Nara Prefecture with Ise Grand Shrine (伊勢神宮)—to explore the phenomenon of pilgrimage across cultures (you can read previous blog posts relating to the project here).
If pilgrimage is a physical and lived undertaking, then using an approach that considers the perceptual and sensory experience of it can help us better understand this phenomenon. Religious experience and associated rituals are also often involve and are indeed heightened by the senses—consider incense, chanting and song, the consumption of bread and wine in the Christian tradition, the washing of hands (temizu 手水) when entering shrines and temples in Japan, all of which can affect and impact how we understand these practices.

For me, walking along these routes opened a completely new perspective on the experience of pilgrimage. I was struck by how tiring it was—I am an experienced walker, but the time spent on foot coupled with navigating, logistics and socialising all day (along with a heightened sense of awareness due to the threat of bears in Japan) left me exhausted at the end of each day. I also came to appreciate how it is almost impossible to truly gauge topography without visiting sites yourself—something Susan and I quickly found out during the first 200 metres of the Ise Honkaido in Japan which felt almost vertical but was barely noticeable on our map. The weather also had a significant impact on our experience of these routes and is something we are exploring through some of our data collected during the walks. I also became more aware of how historic sites related to each other within the landscape from the perspective of past pilgrims, in a time before drone footage, Google Maps and GIS, as I saw churches appearing over the horizon as I walked or came across the many jizo (地蔵 bodhisattva statues) and small shrines along the route in Japan. I was keenly aware of my senses throughout—the different smells, sounds, sights and touchscapes as we passed through different spaces and places. I thought more closely about what would have been eaten or worn or taken as a souvenir by pilgrims of the past as I also made these decisions along the routes.

While we cannot hope to replicate how people of the past experienced these routes, these techniques can enrich our understanding of the breadth of pilgrimage as a phenomenon, as well as encouraging new lines of enquiry by walking these routes ourselves.
Our next post in the series will explore how we can understand senses and sensory experience within our research project, and the innovative digital methods we can use to communicate these findings.
Olivia Butler, October 2026
[1] Two of the key initial works in this field are Maurice Merleau-Ponty The Phenomenology of Perception (1962) and Martin Heidegger Being and Time (1962).
[2] A seminal text on this topic was Chris Tilley’s A Phenomenology of Landscape (1994) and subsequent publications The Materiality of Stone: Explorations in Landscape Phenomenology (2004) and Landscape in the Longue Duree (2017).
[3] For an example of some of these debates, see Olsen, B.J. (2024). ‘Phenomenological Archaeology’ in E. Nikita & T. Rehren (eds.), Encyclopedia of Archaeology (Second Edition). Academic Press, Pp. 429-427.
[4] For a more recent case study using phenomenological and sensory approaches combined with other archaeological techniques such as aerial and field surveys, see Sue Hamilton and Ruth Whitehouse Neolithic Spaces: Social and Sensory Landscapes of the First Farmers of Italy (Volume 1 & 2), 2021.
[5] For discussions relating to phenomenological approaches and cognitive science, see Moyes, H. (2023). ‘The Life and Afterlife of Phenomenology in Archaeological Theory and Practice’. In: Yoshimi, J., Walsh, P., Londen, P. (eds) Horizons of Phenomenology. Contributions to Phenomenology, vol 122. Springer, Cham. https://doi.org/10.1007/978-3-031-26074-2_16
